A Treasury pays 5.1%. Costco’s profits pay 2.1%. One of them is called the safe haven
Ahoy there, Trader! ⚓️
It’s Phil…
In 1999 the future was the internet. In 2021 it was everything. In 2026 the hottest trade on Wall Street is a company that sells toilet roll 30 at a time.
Last week we followed the money out of Nvidia. This is where it went. Costco trades at 49 times this year’s earnings, Walmart at 45, Coca-Cola at 30. A list of ten of these “safe havens” has been doing the rounds, each at or near its richest valuation in decades, with the question underneath: is this the next bubble?
We checked the list and the numbers hold. But a bubble is a bad business at a silly price, and these are good businesses. A good business at a price that needs everything to go right for years just to break even has a plainer name: bloat.
Our Top Trader Uses This 9:50 AM Secret to Target $500 Per Day Regardless Of Which Direction The Market Moves https://antivestor.com/ppp-webinar
The Ten, Sorted
We sorted them on one test: the price you pay per unit of growth. Analysts expect the ten to grow profits by 9.4% next year on average. The S&P 500 is expected to manage 19.5%.
| Stock | Forward P/E | Growth, next year | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| Costco | 48.7 | 9.9% | Bloated |
| Walmart | 44.6 | 11.8% | Bloated |
| Republic Services | 34.8 | 9.9% | Bloated |
| Coca-Cola | 29.8 | 5.7% | Puffy |
| Apple | 37.7 | 10.0% | Puffy |
| Monster | 40.1 | 13.8% | Puffy |
| J&J | 25.7 | 4.0% | Puffy |
| McKesson | 24.1 | 12.8% | Fair |
| AbbVie | 21.1 | 14.7% | Fair |
| Berkshire | 27.0 | 1.2% | Wrong yardstick |
Bloated means a P/E more than four times the long-run growth rate. Puffy is two and a half to four. Berkshire’s earnings swing with its share portfolio, so nobody sensible values it on P/E.
Nutrition information, per share of Costco: earnings yield 2.1%. Dividend 0.5%. Growth 10%. May contain traces of 1999.
For comparison, Nvidia is on 17.5 times and Alphabet on 14.9. The staples sector as a whole is at its highest multiple since 1999 and more than six points dearer than tech, on StockCharts’ numbers. October was the staples fund XLP’s best month since it launched in 1998.

Costco Has Been Here Before
Costco’s trailing multiple has only been above 50 twice. The first time was April 1999, at 56. It is 54 today.
We ran the prices. Costco closed April 2000 at $54.06 in today’s share terms. In May it lost 41% in a month. It was April 2010 before the shares were worth $59. Over that stretch, the Motley Fool reckons, the company doubled its earnings per share. The business did everything asked of it and the shareholders got ten years of nothing.
Walmart did the same thing for longer. It closed 1999 at $23.04 and did not finish a month above that price until June 2012. Profits per share grew 12% a year for the first decade of that wait, by one analyst’s count, while the multiple fell from 44.5 to 13.1. Walmart is on 44.6 today.
Coca-Cola took longest of all.
| Stock | Peak month | Years to get back |
|---|---|---|
| Costco | Apr 2000 | 6 |
| Walmart | Dec 1999 | 12.5 |
| Coca-Cola | Jun 1998 | 16.4 |
First month-end close above the peak month’s close. Price only, so dividends would shorten each wait a little.
None of these companies went bust, missed a dividend or lost its customers. That’s the point about bloat. A bubble pops and you know where you stand. Bloat sits there.
Except When It Doesn’t
On 7 March 2000 Procter & Gamble warned on profits and the shares fell from $87 to $61. It was a soap company. It lost 30% in a day.
Something smaller happened to Costco this June. It missed its earnings forecast by less than 1% and the stock dropped 3.9% on the report. At 49 times earnings there is no such thing as a small miss.
The Safe Haven Pays Less Than a Treasury
The 10-year Treasury yields 5.12% and traders put the odds of a Fed rate rise in December at 95%. Costco’s profits come to 2.1% of its share price. Its dividend is 0.5%. Coca-Cola, the classic income stock, pays 2.1% against a five-year average of 2.9%.
The last time defensive stocks got this dear was the summer of 2016, and there was at least an excuse: the 10-year was at a record low of 1.37%, so a boring stock with a dividend beat a bond. That trade ended when yields turned up. This time yields are already up, and investors are paying more for safety than the government charges for it.
Costco sells a hot dog and a drink for $1.50 and hasn’t raised the price since 1985. The shares are the one item in the warehouse with no discount.
Where the List Cheats
The post sets its safe havens against a “cheap” Nasdaq-100. Four of the ten are in the Nasdaq-100. Walmart moved its listing there last December to be seen as a tech company, joined the index in January, and has got its wish in every respect except the falling share price.
Apple is a tech stock by anyone’s definition. McKesson and AbbVie are growing fast enough to earn their multiples. And the claim that the Nasdaq-100 is near its Covid-era low depends on whose figures you use: one tracker has it at 19.2 times forward earnings, another at 24.5.
The Sums
Give Costco five more years of 10% growth and let the multiple drift from 49 to 30, which would still be a premium to almost every retailer on earth. The share price in 2031 is where it is today.
Do the same for Walmart with a multiple of 25 and the shares are about 10% lower.
What Could Make This Wrong
Costco has traded between 45 and 55 times for most of two years, and people have been calling it expensive since it was 34 times in 2019. Valuation tells you the size of the risk and nothing about the date. StockCharts has a chart target above $1,300. If the AI unwind has further to go, frightened money will keep paying up for toilet roll.
What to Watch
- Tonight: Nvidia reports. A good number is the first thing that could send the money back.
- Thursday 19 Nov, before the open: Walmart reports at 45 times earnings. Watch what the market does with an ordinary beat.
- 9 Dec: the Fed. Every quarter point makes 2.1% look thinner.
- 10 Dec: Costco reports.
Old faithful is still faithful. The geyser goes off on schedule and the hot dog is still $1.50. At 49 times earnings you are paying 1999 prices to stand and watch.
Not investment advice. Three old price charts can’t tell you what these shares do next.
Happy trading,
Phil
Less Brain, More Gain
…and may your trades be smoother than a cashmere codpiece
p.s. There are 3 ways I can help you…
- Option 1: Collect Morning Income
A complete guide to the Premium Popper system.
Written to be clear, concise, and immediately actionable.
>> Learn More Here
- Option 2: Collect Weekly Income
A complete guide to the Tag ‘n Turn system.
>> Learn More Here
- Option 3: Join the Fast Forward Mentorship
>> Join the Fast Forward Mentorship – trade live, twice a week, with me and the crew.
PLUS Monthly on-demand 1-2-1’s
No fluff. Just profits, Tag ‘n Turn Pulse bars, Poppers, and Patterns that actually work.